Refugee rights organisations are demanding an EU-wide temporary protection regime for Syrian refugees. The announcement by some countries that they can take a few thousand refugees is not enough, the groups say.
Sweden has announced a few steps after
the number of Syrian refugees seeking shelter abroad has crossed the two
million mark in early September.
“The conflict will continue for a long time ahead,” said Fredrik
Beijer, director of legal affairs at the Swedish Migration Board. Sweden
decided to grant permanent residence to about 8,000 Syrians who
currently hold temporary residency permits, and to facilitate family
Germany and the Scandinavian country have between them received about
two-thirds of the Syrian refugees fleeing to Europe. Since early 2012,
approximately 14,700 Syrians have asked for asylum in Sweden. In August
alone, 1,201 Syrian asylum-seekers arrived in the country.
On Sep. 11, 107 Syrian refugees were flown out of Lebanon to Hanover
as part of a temporary admission programme announced by the German
government earlier this year. Having committed to 5,000 places, Germany
currently runs the biggest refugee relocation programme for the Syria
In June, the UN Refugee Agency (UNHCR) appealed for 10,000
humanitarian admissions. A group of countries including Denmark,
Finland, the Netherlands, Norway and Spain have pledged 960 admissions
for 2013 so far.
“Germany is setting an important example,” UNHCR spokesperson Dan
McNorton told IPS. “We hope more countries will come forward with
similar schemes to help Syrians fleeing the violence.”
Germany’s two smaller neighbours Switzerland and Austria have pledged
to accommodate 500 refugees each. Austria’s foreign minister preference
for Christian refugees recently drew harsh criticism.
Compared to the hundreds of thousands of Syrian refugees stranded in
Turkey, Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt and Iraq, the estimated 40,000 that have
applied for asylum in Europe since April 2011 is peanuts.
A comparison with the Bosnian war between 1992 and 1995 makes today’s
numbers look dismal. At the time, Germany hosted 350,000 Bosnian
refugees, Austria 90,000 and Switzerland nearly 30,000. During the Kosovo war, Germany evacuated more than 15,000 refugees, while Switzerland sheltered 53,000 and Austria 5,000.
The Swiss chapter of Amnesty International calls Switzerland’s
present offer “a drop in the ocean.” Austrian and German refugee rights
organisations have also criticised their governments.
“Germany’s contribution is yet too small,” Karl Kopp, director of
European affairs at the human rights organisation Pro Asyl told IPS,
“though, we appreciate that Germany has launched the debate.”
In addition to the 5,000, several German states have announced they
will permit up to 1,000 Syrian refugees to stay with their Germany-based
relatives. Kopp said that many of these have been trying desperately to
get their relatives to come over.
Bureaucratic hurdles for family reunification are high, as Syrians
already living in Germany have to prove they can provide for their
relatives, host them and pay for their health insurance. “Most of them
are unable to do so. But humanity mustn’t fail due to lack of money,”
While Switzerland is facilitating family reunification, too, Austria
hesitates to do so. In Austria, upcoming parliamentary elections reduce
the willingness of politicians to invite refugees to the country.
Meanwhile, thousands of Syrian refugees are trying hard to find a way
into Europe. According to the Italian interior ministry, 3,000 Syrians
have already arrived in Italy since the beginning of the year, most of
them in boats. At Europe’s other entry gate, Greek coastguards have
repeatedly been accused of pushing Syrian refugees back into Turkish
“That is outrageous,” says Kopp. “Europe needs to open legal escape
routes. Currently, Europe asks Syria’s neighbours to open up their
borders, while its own borders remain closed.”
Anny Knapp, president of the Austrian refugee rights organisation
Asylkoordination Österreich says refugees have to turn to the risky and
expensive services of people smugglers, as no legal escape routes exist.
“In addition, the Dublin regulation forecloses that refugees can
profit from family or community ties in other European states,” says
Knapp. According to the Dublin regulation, immigrants may be sent back
to the country through which they first entered the European Union.
Knapp’s German counterpart Karl Kopp therefore demands freedom of movement for Syrian refugees within Europe.
Judith Sunderland, senior researcher at Human Rights Watch told IPS
that Syrians seeking asylum in other EU member states face a protection
lottery, with their fate depending on which country they reach first.
“Those who make it to the EU through external border countries such
as Greece, Bulgaria and Cyprus can face problems such as detention,
failure to be granted any form of protection, problems with family
reunification as well as poor or non-existent reception conditions.”
All refugee rights advocates agree that action at the European level is required urgently.
Kopp finds it “absolutely pathetic” that three years after the
beginning of the Syria crisis the EU still doesn’t have an active
admission programme. In June, the European Commission had called upon
its member states to provide resettlement or humanitarian admission
places, to facilitate family reunification and “to admit any Syrians
arriving at the external borders of the Union.”
The European Commission also promised to continue efforts to ensure a
greater degree of convergence between member states’ approaches to the
Syrian refugee crisis. Yet it is far from providing a concerted solution
like a EU-wide temporary protection regime, repeating its failure
during the Libya war in 2011.
Instead, tons of tents and blankets are sent to Syria’s neighbour
states. “Even though they think that the Syrian refugee crisis can be
contained regionally, it has in fact long reached Europe,” says Kopp.
“The catastrophe’s dimensions render such an approach not just absurd,
but highly cynical.”
This report was first published here by IPS Inter Press Service.